The ongoing debate between the significance of brand versus product often centers around two factors that drive success: emotional resonance or functional excellence. Yet, this debate is rarely a matter of choosing one over the other, as businesses thrive when both elements work together effectively. User experience (UX) and service design play critical roles in shaping the overall product interaction, influencing both its success and the company’s reputation.
While a great user experience alone might not rescue a subpar product, can an exceptional brand compensate for a less-than-ideal product? Similarly, does a poor brand image have the power to undermine even the best product?
Place, People, and the Past
X (formerly Twitter) has been making headlines recently due to a significant user exodus. Over 115,000 users have abandoned the platform since November 2024, turning to alternatives like BlueSky, Threads, and Mastodon. Between November 5 and 15, BlueSky’s user base in the U.S. surged by 519%. Many former users cite issues such as bots, AI models, excessive ads, negative interactions, and political content as reasons for the shift. Is this a reflection of the product, or the brand itself? Will X face a similar fate to platforms like MySpace or Google+?
Reed’s Law posits that the value of a social network lies in its ability to enable group formation rather than individual connections. A platform that allows users to define their interactions and create groups around shared interests offers a personalized experience. Given that this is achievable across various platforms, what drives an individual’s choice between them?
Branding and Product Experience
X, Threads, and Mastodon all offer similar text-based social media platforms, but do they truly offer something new or innovative to users? Absent a significant leap in innovation or market demand, can branding or business strategy determine whether these platforms succeed or fail in engaging users?
Emotional grounding—the connection to a place, people, or past—will become increasingly important in shaping both digital and physical products. This emotional attachment is not limited to physical goods but extends to the experiences offered by digital products and services.
The Faces Behind the Brands
Many digital products today are associated with influential figures, such as Elon Musk with X, Steve Jobs and Tim Cook with Apple, Bill Gates with Microsoft, and Mark Zuckerberg with Facebook. These leaders impact the perception of the brand and product, influencing both adoption and engagement. Companies like Figma, Adobe, LinkedIn, and Vimeo, however, do not rely on celebrity founders. Does the CEO figure play a role in brand endorsement, or is it more about CEO branding itself?
Elizabeth (Zab) Johnson of the Wharton Neuroscience Initiative notes, “Celebrities in advertising can either bolster the product or detract from it by drawing attention away from the actual product.” The presence of a well-known CEO can help foster a connection with consumers and inspire trust, but can this influence extend to companies without high-profile leaders? When there is no famous CEO, can confidence still be built solely through the product experience?
Is Content Still King?
In 1996, Bill Gates famously proclaimed, “Content is King,” predicting that the internet would revolutionize how we access and distribute information and entertainment. Yet, as digital platforms evolve, we engage with content in increasingly diverse ways. Users today follow companies and individuals for content that may have little to do with the product itself.
Take Reddit, for example: users flock to the platform for the community and content, not necessarily because of branding. Its appeal lies in anonymity, niche interests, and the ability to engage with like-minded individuals outside one’s social circle. But in today’s landscape, where similar content is available across numerous platforms, what truly drives a user’s decision—content or experience?
The Rise of AI: Innovation or Marketing?
The dot-com bubble of the late 1990s witnessed an influx of tech companies, many without solid business plans, leading to a market crash. Today, we face a similar situation with AI-enhanced products. Are these AI innovations driven by genuine technological advancements, or are they part of a marketing push fueled by the fear of missing out (FOMO)?
For instance, AI claims on products like washing machines from 2012 seemed more about branding than innovation. In 2024, we must ask ourselves if the proliferation of AI in products is about adding real value, or merely to keep up with market trends.
Building Meaningful Products
Henry Ford famously said, “If I had asked my customers what they wanted, they would have said faster horses.” This insight highlights the challenge in understanding consumer needs and using that understanding to create innovative solutions. Ford’s quote speaks to the importance of product innovation that solves real problems, rather than simply giving customers what they think they want.
Take the Segway, for example. While it was a technological marvel, its failure in the market can be attributed to its focus on innovation over practical value. In contrast, modern electric scooters, which prioritize user convenience, have found tremendous success. The Segway’s focus on complex technology at a high price point failed to align with consumer needs.
Does this suggest that product experience can outweigh technological innovation? In many cases, the experience reigns supreme over the brand or the sheer novelty of the product.
Technology Enhancing Jobs, Not Replacing Them
AI will not replace jobs like design or development but will instead enhance them, just as development frameworks and content management systems did in the past. AI has the potential to revolutionize fields by automating tasks and creating new opportunities. It can draft design systems, streamline development, and make complex tasks accessible to a wider audience.
However, just as users do not want their websites to “look like WordPress,” the desire to create unique user experiences remains strong. This highlights the ongoing tension between using familiar tools for efficiency versus the drive to differentiate through design.
The Role of Branding in Product Design
Just as branding has evolved over time, so too has its role in influencing consumer decisions. From simple logos representing ownership to more complex brand identities representing values and personal connections, the impact of branding on product choice is undeniable. Take, for example, Jaguar’s recent logo redesign to signal its move into electric vehicles. The change reflects a shift in both the company’s values and the visual identity of the brand.
In the digital space, the experience of using a product often outweighs the brand’s appeal. Whether it’s a hospital’s choice of software or a consumer’s choice of app, decisions are driven by both the functionality and the experience provided.
The Role of Trust in Brand and Product Success
Trust is an essential ingredient in the success of both a brand and its products. When consumers trust a brand, they are more likely to try its products—even in the face of competition. A brand that consistently delivers quality and reliability builds loyalty. Apple, for instance, has earned immense customer trust by providing top-notch products that consistently meet user expectations. When a product or brand gains consumer trust, it can effectively navigate crises and setbacks, ensuring long-term success.
On the flip side, a brand that loses consumer trust, whether due to poor product quality or unethical practices, can quickly become irrelevant, even if the product is of high quality. This is where emotional grounding—creating a deep connection to a brand’s values and purpose—can play a pivotal role in retaining consumer loyalty.
The Changing Landscape of Branding and Personalization
With the rise of AI and big data, brands are now able to personalize user experiences like never before. Brands like Netflix and Spotify have revolutionized their industries by curating content based on individual user preferences, creating an experience that feels bespoke. This shift toward personalization not only enhances the product experience but also strengthens the emotional connection between consumers and brands.
Personalization has extended beyond content recommendations to product offerings, where brands can tailor services or products based on consumer behaviors, preferences, and even geographical locations. In a world where consumers are bombarded with choices, the ability to deliver personalized experiences can be a key differentiator for a brand.
The Emotional and Functional Balance in Digital Products
Digital products, particularly in the realm of SaaS (Software as a Service), have blurred the lines between emotional connection and functional value. While businesses initially focused on functionality—providing tools to help users perform tasks more effectively—the success of many products today lies in how they make users feel. For example, Slack didn’t just offer a functional messaging tool for teams; it created an experience where communication felt more natural and connected, fostering a sense of community.
Similarly, platforms like Duolingo have mastered the balance of emotion and function by incorporating gamification elements, creating an enjoyable and rewarding experience while also being highly functional in terms of language learning.
The Impact of Consumer Behavior on Product Evolution
Consumer behavior constantly shapes the direction of product development. In today’s fast-paced market, companies need to be agile, responding quickly to shifting consumer preferences. A product that was once revolutionary can quickly become obsolete if it doesn’t evolve with its users’ changing needs. A great example of this is how the smartphone industry has shifted from simply being a communication tool to an all-encompassing device used for everything from social media to mobile banking.
It’s not just about adapting technology—brands must also stay attuned to cultural shifts, social movements, and global events to remain relevant. The rise of sustainability concerns, for example, has prompted many brands to adopt environmentally friendly practices and eco-conscious products. Consumers now not only choose brands based on the quality of the product but also based on shared values such as environmental responsibility.
The Importance of User-Centric Design
As the demand for seamless, intuitive experiences grows, user-centric design has become more important than ever. A good product experience goes beyond functionality; it must also prioritize usability. Products that are easy to navigate, require minimal effort, and deliver quick results have an edge over those that complicate the user journey. This is where UX design, combined with emotional intelligence, plays a critical role.
For instance, the success of platforms like Airbnb and Uber isn’t just based on their ability to connect users with hosts or drivers. The design of the app experience—how easy it is to search for listings, book rides, and make payments—makes a huge difference in user satisfaction. This user-centric focus helps build lasting relationships and increases brand loyalty.
The Role of Visual Identity in Building Brand Recall
Visual identity, including logos, colors, typography, and overall design aesthetics, plays a major role in brand recognition. A well-crafted visual identity ensures that a brand is easily identifiable and evokes the right emotions. Think about brands like Coca-Cola or Nike—both use their iconic logos to communicate a sense of happiness, freedom, and success. A strong visual identity can transcend the product itself and become a symbol of the brand’s values.
In the digital space, visual consistency across all touchpoints—whether it’s a website, app, or social media presence—reinforces the brand’s message and makes it easier for users to connect emotionally. Visual design is not just about appearance; it’s about conveying a message that resonates with the consumer on a deeper level.
The Power of Community in Digital Product Success
Community has emerged as one of the most powerful tools for enhancing user engagement. Social platforms like Reddit, Discord, and even niche groups within Facebook offer users a sense of belonging. These communities often help drive the growth and success of digital products. When users feel a sense of community, they are more likely to advocate for a brand and engage with its product regularly.
The power of community extends beyond social networks to product ecosystems. Companies like Apple and Tesla have created strong communities around their products, where users not only consume the product but also discuss and share experiences with others, strengthening the brand’s presence.
Consumer-Driven Innovation and Crowdsourcing
In recent years, consumer-driven innovation has become a powerful force. More and more companies are turning to crowdsourcing to gather insights directly from users. This direct feedback loop allows businesses to quickly adapt products to meet consumer demands and identify emerging trends. Platforms like Kickstarter and Indiegogo have popularized crowdsourcing, enabling startups to launch products with direct input from the people who will eventually buy them.
Crowdsourcing helps not only in product development but also in marketing. A product’s initial user base can become its most loyal advocates, spreading the word and building brand trust. By involving customers in the creation process, companies can ensure that their products are highly attuned to market needs.
Will AI Define the Future of Product Design?
AI is poised to transform the design process by personalizing user experiences. Will it create tailored interfaces, content strategies, and even visual elements based on individual user preferences? As brands continue to evolve and products become increasingly integrated into our daily lives, we must consider whether they are statements of support for the brand, solutions to problems, or both.
Ultimately, whether it’s the brand, product, or user experience, the question remains: What truly influences consumer choice?
image credit: https://www.freepik.com/
